Medication/Exercise Therapy Combo Reduces Knee Pain

August 29, 2015
Rita Baron-Faust MPH

Combo therapy alleviates osteoarthritis knee pain enough to resume disease modifying exercise therapy.

A combination of muscle strength training, aerobic training and pain medication has been shown to diminish knee pain enough to allow patients to resume regular exercise therapy. Exercise therapy is one of the most effective interventions for knee osteoarthritis, but for many patients, the pain is so severe, that participating in an exercise therapy program is impossible. Now, a new study of 49 patients finds that combining muscle strength training and some aerobic training with a step-up protocol of analgesics, alleviates enough knee pain to encourage patients to follow a regular exercise therapy regime. The study appears in the August 3 online issue of Arthritis Care & Research. The researchers, led by Marike van der Leeden, PhD, a physical therapist at the Amsterdam Rehabilitation Research Center in Reade, call the newly developed intervention protocol “a significant innovation” that provides assistance in clinical reasoning of rheumatologists and PTs in the complex treatment of patients with severe knee pain.”

 

  • Optimization of analgesics is a key in order to be able to participate in exercise therapy.

​

  • Exercise reduces pain and activity limitations in patients with knee osteoarthritis and severe pain. Source: Arthritis Care & Research

 The study included 49 participants (42 were women) with a median age of 64 and pain scores of 7 or above on the Numeric Rating Scale. After a six week standardized regimen of analgesic medications, such as acetaminophen, NSAIDs, opioids and IA injection, the patients were enrolled in a 12-week exercise therapy program.  The program consisted of six weeks of twice-weekly sessions targeting muscle strength (low intensity exercises). During the second phase, exercise intensity increased with the addition of aerobic training, such as a treadmill and cross-trainer. Statistically significant improvements were found during the first six weeks with further improvements in final weeks of the trial. In total, 78% (n=36) of patients participated in 80% of the exercise therapy program. Improvements of 30% (p<0.001) from baseline for pain and 17% (p<0.001) from baseline for activity limitations were found after 18 weeks. Patients used one or more pain medications – including acetaminophen (95.5%), NSAIDs such as ibuprofen or naproxen (40.9%), weak opioids like tramadol or codeine (34.1%) – and 2 patients had steroid injections in the knee joint.  Doses were increased as needed by physicians with the goal of decreasing pain scores to at or below 5 on the NRS before the exercise program began. This was achieved in only 36% of patients. Patients who could not participate in exercise therapy according to the protocol had significantly more severe radiological symptoms of osteoarthritis and had insufficient pain reduction at the 6 week mark.  The study was limited by lack of a control group and the results need to be confirmed in a randomized controlled trial, the researchers wrote.  In a review article published in the same issue of

Arthritis Care & Research

, Marcas Bamman, PhD, of the University of Alabama, and colleagues, support the adoption of proposed treatment guidelines for osteoarthritis and more randomized, controlled trials. Treatment guidelines have been proposed by the American College of Rheumatology. “We fully support this recommendation but also recognize that it falls short of a well-defined exercise prescription because data [[{"type":"media","view_mode":"media_crop","fid":"40874","attributes":{"alt":"","class":"media-image media-image-right","id":"media_crop_5131862650159","media_crop_h":"0","media_crop_image_style":"-1","media_crop_instance":"4243","media_crop_rotate":"0","media_crop_scale_h":"0","media_crop_scale_w":"0","media_crop_w":"0","media_crop_x":"0","media_crop_y":"0","style":"font-size: 13.0080003738403px; line-height: 1.538em; float: right;","title":" ","typeof":"foaf:Image"}}]]from randomized, controlled trials comparing doses are sorely lacking,” they write. “Rigorous, large-scale trials are needed to provide the evidence base that should incentivize both clinicians and patients to adhere to prescribed exercise regimens. “We suggest that this research should aim to: i) optimize both dose-response effectiveness and adherence; ii) identify genetic and phenotypic determinants of responsiveness; and, iii) better understand the interactive effects (e.g., synergism, antagonism) between exercise and both common and novel drug/device treatments.  “In our view, the high rates of inactivity among persons with osteoarthritis are troubling, and should fuel a robust, multi-tiered research effort with aims of optimizing exercise prescription to improve adherence and effectiveness in osteoarthritis .” 

Why is Exercise Prescription Important?

  • Exercise can manage symptoms of osteoarthritis such as pain reduction and reduced fatigue
  • It could slow the loss of tissue and joint function
  • Sedentary time confers an alarmingly elevated risk of multiple morbidities (diabetes, cardiovascular events, CV mortality and all-cause mortality.

RELATED COVERAGE

  

References:

van Tunen JAC, van der Leeden M, H Bos WH. Optimization of analgesics allows patients with knee osteoarthritis ad severe pain to participate in exercise therapy – a feasibility study.Arthritis Care & Research. Aug. 3, 2015. DOI: 10.1002/acr.22682.  

 Marcas M Bamman PhD, Timothy M Wick PhD, Carlos A. Carmona-Moran MS, and S. Louis Bridges Jr., MD, PhD.

Exercise Medicine for Osteoarthritis: Research Strategies to Maximize Effectiveness. Arthritis Care & Research.

Aug. 3, 2015. DOI: 10.1002/acr.22680.